A British commentator’s detention by US authorities underscores the Trump administration’s stance against perceived supporters of terrorism.
Story Highlights
- Sami Hamdi, a British journalist, detained in the US for celebrating a Hamas attack.
- Hamdi’s visa was revoked, and he faces deportation.
- The US government cites national security and anti-terrorism measures.
- CAIR condemns the detention as a violation of free speech.
Detention of Sami Hamdi at US Airport
Sami Hamdi, a British commentator known for his outspoken support of Palestinian causes, was detained by US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) at San Francisco International Airport on October 26, 2025. Hamdi’s detention follows his public praise for Hamas’s October 7, 2023, attack on Israel, which resulted in over 1,200 civilian deaths. The Trump administration has taken a hardline stance, revoking Hamdi’s visa and preparing to deport him, citing national security concerns.
Political and Advocacy Responses
The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) has strongly condemned Hamdi’s detention, framing it as an affront to free speech. Hamdi had been on a US speaking tour, sponsored by CAIR, promoting dialogue on Palestinian rights. His detention has sparked debate over the balance between national security and freedom of expression, with CAIR arguing that the action is politically motivated due to Hamdi’s criticism of Israel and US policies.
Pro-Israel activists, however, support the detention, asserting that Hamdi’s public statements amount to support for terrorism. They argue that his exclusion is a necessary measure to protect American interests and prevent the spread of extremist ideologies. This view aligns with the Trump administration’s immigration policies, which prioritize national security and counter-terrorism efforts.
Implications for US Immigration Policy
This case highlights the broader implications for US immigration policy under the Trump administration. By detaining and preparing to deport individuals like Hamdi, the administration reinforces its commitment to preventing entry to foreign nationals perceived as security threats. This approach is likely to deter similar pro-Palestinian advocacy by foreign nationals in the US, potentially impacting academic, journalistic, and civil rights exchanges.
UK commentator who celebrated Hamas’ Oct. 7 terror attack is detained at US airport https://t.co/tM6qnr99vd pic.twitter.com/KGFeKGWBoR
— New York Post (@nypost) October 27, 2025
While Hamdi remains in ICE custody, the situation underscores the complex intersection of immigration law, national security, and free speech. As the Trump administration continues to enforce stringent immigration controls, the debate over the limits of free expression and the role of advocacy groups in shaping public discourse is likely to intensify.
Sources:
British journalist Sami Hamdi praised Oct. 7 attacks, USA
Sami Hamdi detained supporting terrorism
US detains British commentator during speaking tour, apparently over anti-Israel comments
British commentator detained by ICE after Israel criticism on US book tour









